Your submission is now in Draft mode.

Once it's ready, please submit your draft for review by our team of Community Moderators. Thank you!

Submit Essay

Once you submit your essay, you can no longer edit it.


This content now needs to be approved by community moderators.


This essay was submitted and is waiting for review.

Discussion: Domain System

{{qctrl.question.commentStr()}} {{qctrl.question.estimateReadingTime()}} min read

As described in this news item, a new Metaculus "domain" system has recently quietly gone live.

In short, the idea is that it is now very easy to create domains, which create sub-divisions of the full metaculus community (which we've started referring to as "Metaculus prime", or "MP"). The idea of a domain is:

  • Each question has a set of domains associated with it, and it appears on those domains.

  • Each user has a set of domains to which they have access, but all users have access to MP.

  • Each domain has a top-level URL of form [domain]

  • Each domain has its own leaderboard, and can have some other customizations, such as a few different look-and-feel options, different categories, etc.

  • Users carry some of their information (levels, powers etc.) across domains but not all of it (with details TBD.)

The hope here is that domains can be used in a few different ways, e.g.,

  • By a group or organization that wishes to create a set of questions private to that group, but optionally cross-post some of them to MP.

  • By Metaculus or another group wishing to create a domain focusing in much greater detail on some particular issue, where some of the "top line" questions would be cross-posted to MP, but some finer-grained or more technical questions would be domain-specific.

We're currently in the process of integrating what was previously a private instance,, into the domain system. So you'll probably start to see some cross-posted questions soon.

This discussion question is to invite feedback. For example:

  • Questions about how domains work?

  • What uses do you see for domains?

  • How should some of the details work? For example:

    • Should you carry your level and score across all domains, or should it be individual to the domain, or both?

    • What happens when a question is cross-posted when it's already opened?

Metaculus Itself