This Discussion is now a Draft.

Once it's ready, please submit it for review by our team of Community Moderators. Thank you!


This Discussion now needs to be approved by community moderators.

Discussion: Domain System

As described in this news item, a new Metaculus "domain" system has recently quietly gone live.

In short, the idea is that it is now very easy to create domains, which create sub-divisions of the full metaculus community (which we've started referring to as "Metaculus prime", or "MP"). The idea of a domain is:

  • Each question has a set of domains associated with it, and it appears on those domains.

  • Each user has a set of domains to which they have access, but all users have access to MP.

  • Each domain has a top-level URL of form [domain].metaculus.com

  • Each domain has its own leaderboard, and can have some other customizations, such as a few different look-and-feel options, different categories, etc.

  • Users carry some of their information (levels, powers etc.) across domains but not all of it (with details TBD.)

The hope here is that domains can be used in a few different ways, e.g.,

  • By a group or organization that wishes to create a set of questions private to that group, but optionally cross-post some of them to MP.

  • By Metaculus or another group wishing to create a domain focusing in much greater detail on some particular issue, where some of the "top line" questions would be cross-posted to MP, but some finer-grained or more technical questions would be domain-specific.

We're currently in the process of integrating what was previously a private instance, ai.metaculus.com, into the domain system. So you'll probably start to see some cross-posted questions soon.

This discussion question is to invite feedback. For example:

  • Questions about how domains work?

  • What uses do you see for domains?

  • How should some of the details work? For example:

    • Should you carry your level and score across all domains, or should it be individual to the domain, or both?

    • What happens when a question is cross-posted when it's already opened?

Metaculus Itself