
$10,000 Prize Pool for the U.S. Democracy Threat Index
23
**Update, December 11, 2025**: We’re excited to announce that Bright Line Watch and Metaculus have partnered to establish a **\$10,000** prize pool for the U.S. Democracy Threat Index to further support its mission of tracking U.S. institutional resilience in real time. \$7,500 will be awarded based on your predictions from December 12, 2025 onwards so that the index remains continuously updated as events unfold. The remaining \$2,500 will be awarded based on periodic snapshots of your forecasts taken during the tournament. These snapshots will be timed to coincide with Bright Line Watch's surveys of experts and the American public, enabling a direct comparison between them and the Metaculus community. The first snapshot will be taken on **January 1, 2026 at 00:00 UTC**. Make sure to submit your forecasts on all questions before this date! *** When does political conflict become institutional crisis? Are courts being defied? Is voting access restricted? Is independent journalism being suppressed? In an era of constant crisis headlines, tracking concrete, measurable events can help us identify genuine threats. Our new [<u>U.S. Democracy Threat Index</u>](https://www.metaculus.com/index/us-democracy-threat/?page=4) combines 39 concrete forecast questions into a single metric tracking institutional resilience. These indicators were selected by our returning partners at [<u>Bright Line Watch</u>](https://brightlinewatch.org/), a nonpartisan group of political scientists from Dartmouth and other leading institutions who have monitored democratic norms since 2017. After news breaks, forecasters update, and the index moves or doesn’t. That gap between headlines and index movement provides a signal of which events actually impact democratic health and which don’t. The higher the index climbs toward 100, the greater the threat to democratic institutions; the lower it falls toward 0, the more resilient democracy appears. [<u>Learn about indexes</u>](https://www.metaculus.com/notebooks/31879/announcing-indexes/).  ## **39 Questions Across Six Critical Areas** The index tracks specific, measurable outcomes identified by BLW as genuine indicators of democratic health across six areas of concern. The index value is the average probability of the event happening in each period. Below find the areas along with an example question from each: **Electoral integrity and competition** * [<u>Will courts block election certification based on fraud claims?</u>](https://www.metaculus.com/questions/39743/us-court-block-certification-of-any-statewide-election-result-because-of-fraud/) **Political rights and participation** * [<u>Will opposing parties block major nominees from the ballot?</u>](https://www.metaculus.com/questions/39754/will-the-oppositiony-block-a-nominee-for-us-statewide-office-from-the-ballot/) **Civil liberties and expression** * [<u>Will journalists be charged under the Espionage Act?</u>](https://www.metaculus.com/questions/39788/doj-files-charges-against-journalist-under-espionage-act-in-these-years/) **Rule of law and anti-corruption** * [<u>Will 10+ presidential affiliates receive pardons?</u>](https://www.metaculus.com/questions/39794/10-us-president-affiliated-people-to-get-a-pardoncommutation-in-these-years/) **Institutional checks and balances** * [<u>Will executive officials defy federal court orders?</u>](https://www.metaculus.com/questions/39802/will-the-us-executive-order-non-enforcement-of-court-orders-in-these-years/) **Information integrity and influence** * [<u>Will SCOTUS weaken campaign finance disclosure rules?</u>](https://www.metaculus.com/questions/39808/will-scotus-weaken-donor-disclosure-rules-for-political-spending-in-these-years/) [<u>View all 39 questions in the index</u>](https://www.metaculus.com/index/us-democracy-threat/?page=4) ## How Questions Work Each question covers two-year periods from 2021-2028. Historical data has been backfilled, providing base rates to calibrate predictions for 2025-2026 and 2027-2028. For example, the question about White House targeting of critics resolved "No" for 2021-2022 and 2023-2024, but "Yes" for 2025-2026 following recent security clearance revocations. ## How to Participate Visit the [<u>U.S. Democracy Threat Index</u>](https://www.metaculus.com/index/us-democracy-threat/?page=4) to: * **Forecast individual questions**: Share predictions on all 39 indicators * **Track the index**: Watch aggregate forecasts evolve with events * **Use historical baselines**: Reference past resolutions to inform predictions Forecast to contribute to a real-time assessment of American democracy's trajectory. Your predictions provide a dynamic indicator of democratic health that will be compared with predictions from dozens of political science researchers from a range of institutions. 